Report – Condemned to Unemployment: East Jerusalem Women Struggle for Integration into the Labor Market

8)        The Employment Service Helps Sustain Abusive Employment

In 2016 an average of 2,906 EJ women per month attended the EB, which supplied 3,048 job referrals in the course of the year.[21] That is a large number of referrals relative to the 11,000 who are employed in EJ. Thus the EB is a significant conduit for job referrals here, and it bears a great responsibility.

We have learned, however, that a large number of referrals does not indicate a large supply of jobs. In 2016, many women who turned to WAC had been referred to employers who said they had no need for new workers and had not requested any. Nevertheless, on numerous occasions the employer would report to the EB that the worker had refused the job, which would result in the denial of income support for two months—as in the following example.

On September 2, 2015, Rania Julani, whose story appears above, was referred to a company as a cleaner. At the time she was also taking a vocational course to which the Rian Center had referred her and for which the EB was paying her tuition. During the job interview, she was asked repeatedly, in many variations, whether she wanted to work. After answering each time in the affirmative, she was asked about her health. She said that her health was fine and that nothing would hinder her. She was then asked if she had children and if that would impede her. On answering that she does indeed have children but that she wants to work, she was asked whether she is studying. Yes, she said. In that case, said the employer, I conclude that you do not want to work. Julani replied that she wants both to work and study in parallel, so that she can earn a bigger salary one day. The employer answered that he found her unsuitable. A week later the clerk at the EB told her that her benefit was denied because the employer reported that she had said that she prefers to study and not to work. With WAC’s help, Julani then went through months of legal wrangling, until finally the EB erased its classification of refusal.  Much to our regret, the behaviour of the employer in this case is not unusual. In the same period we approached the company in the name of additional jobseekers, male and female, who had received similar treatment. On one occasion the manager even said that in fact they do not need workers at all and had never asked the EB for any.

Despite the fact that much material has been given to the EB about these cases, both in written submissions and via appeals to Appeals Tribunals and the Labor Court, no evidence has reached us that the EB has looked into these cases. The opposite is true: We know that the EB continues to refer women to these employers; there continue to be cases where the employer reports a job refusal while the women claim that it was they who were refused. The EB overwhelmingly sides with the employer, because its official stated position is to assume that the employer has no reason to lie.

Referrals to Abusive Jobs

A job seeker who is referred by the EB does not have the right to question the nature of the work to which she has been referred, without risking the loss of the income support to which she is entitled for two months. This fact, against the background of the deep poverty in EJ, bestows great power on employers, who can exploit jobseekers who are in no position to refuse.

In our experience, as shown by the examples in the present report, the employer’s power is often abused, forcing women to choose between abusive employment or loss of income support. In addition, women often find that despite their efforts to be accepted, employers refuse them; many a time this is wrongly interpreted by the EB as if the woman had refused.

During 2016 many such cases turned up at the WAC office. We had to launch claims and appeals, and we also made written submissions to the EB. The latter refused to examine the behaviour of the employers. Yet our appeals to the Labor Court resulted in the nullification of these refusals even before the hearing. In effect, the nullification prevented a fundamental examination of the phenomenon and the issues involved. Attorney Emanuel Weill from the legal department of the EB, in response to an application, refused to address the issue, claiming that WAC had no right to raise a complaint on the matter. His position tallies with clarifications by the EB spokesperson, who said, “The Service does not conduct inspections of employers,” claiming it was not in its jurisdiction unless there was an accumulation of claims at the EB Ombudsman’s office which had been adjudicated as justified.

This policy, whether it is legal or supported by a lenient interpretation of the law, provides fertile ground for abusive employers to exploit a cheap and vulnerable labor force.

MORE...

The East Jerusalem Project

Hadaya’s case: She had to leave her job for health reasons. With support from MAAN she received all her rights as a laid-off employee

Hadaya, 58, a woman from East Jerusalem, is the sole provider for her family. Her six children depend on her. She did not want to leave her job, but due to her deteriorating health she could not continue working. With the help of MAAN – Workers Association, she received the full severance pay that is due to someone who resigns due to a medical condition, and secured her entitlement to unemployment benefits from day one.

READ MORE »
Palestinian Workers

Instead of Showy Arrests, Let Palestinian Workers Return to Construction

The ceasefire agreement between Israel and Hezbollah, which came into effect on Wednesday, November 27, marks the end of the war in Lebanon. If it holds, a period of reconstruction will begin, bringing a dramatic increase in the need for workers in the construction sector. Meanwhile, tens of thousands of Palestinians are waiting for the government to allow them back into construction sites in Israel. Thousands of contractors are also desperate for skilled labor, reporting that the foreign workers they have managed to recruit are too few and insufficiently trained.

READ MORE »
Uncategorized

New Beekeepers Receive their Diploma and Join the “Bees for Peace” Family

The smiles on the faces of the 17 graduates of the beekeeping course were uplifting. The buzz in the room even resembled the hum of a beehive. Since the course ended in June, these women have been busy maintaining the beehive each received for her home. The certificate ceremony took place on September 9 at the “MAAN Workers’ Association branch in Baqa al-Gharbiya, attended by course graduates, the project’s leading team, and members of the MAAN’s women’s forum.

READ MORE »

אנא כתבו את שמכם המלא, טלפון ותיאור קצר של נושא הפנייה, ונציג\ה של מען יחזרו אליכם בהקדם האפשרי.

رجاءً اكتبوا اسمكم الكامل، الهاتف، ووصف قصير حول موضوع توجهكم، ومندوب عن نقابة معًا سيعاود الاتصال بكم لاحقًا








As an organization committed to the rights of workers without distinction of religion, race, nationality, gender, or profession - democracy is our essence. We strongly oppose the authoritarian laws that the extreme government of Netanyahu, Lapid, Bennett, and Smotrich is attempting to impose.

Without democracy, there are no workers' rights, just as a workers' organization cannot exist under dictatorship.

only a victory of the democratic camp will enable a discussion on the Palestinian issue and lead to an alternative solution to occupation and apartheid while ensuring human rights and citizenship for all, Israelis and Palestinians alike. As long as the apartheid regime persists, the democratic camp will not succeed in defeating Israeli extremists. Therefore, we work to involve the Arab and Palestinian society in the protest.

We invite you:

To march with us in protests and to build an alternative, democratic, Jewish-Arab professional union in Israel. Join our quiet WhatsApp group today, "Marching with us in protest."

To join MAAN and unite workers in your workplace. Read here how to join the organization.

To follow MAAN's work on social networks.

Please write your full name, phone number, and a brief description of the subject of your inquiry, and a representative from our organization will get back to you as soon as possible.